🚫🚬 Di Judge Throway F.D.A. Law wey wan Control Big Man Cigars
⬇️ Pidgin ⬇️ ⬇️ Black American Slang ⬇️ English
E shock everybody wen federal judge come say Food and Drug Administration (F.D.A.) no fit control those correct, hand-rolled cigars for Wednesday. This na better tori for those people wey dey make this big man cigar wey dem dey show for film and big party dem.
Since 2016, di people wey dey produce cigar don dey battle F.D.A. for court becos of di rule wey dem bring. But last year dem score goal as U.S. District Judge Amit P. Mehta come tell F.D.A. say dem no follow correct process as dem wan put hand for di matter of this kind cigar.
Di rule wey di judge bring out now na for those kind cigars wey dem dey roll with hand and dem dey sell am inside special box for those correct stores, no be like those cheap cigars wey machine dey produce wey you fit see buy anywhere.
Wen Drew Newman wey be di ogbonge man for J.C. Newman Cigar Co. for Tampa, Fla. hear di tori, e go find one old cigar wey im papa do tey tey. Oga Newman come light am take celebrate. E say e dey happy say dem fit carry di way dem take dey roll cigar pass am to their pikin dem.
No Be Everybody Dey Dance 💃🚫
Some health group like American Lung Association, American Heart Association, plus even American Academy of Pediatrics and di American Cancer Society don write letter give court make dem no throway this law.
Thomas Carr wey be oga for American Lung Association come talk say this new rule no follow at all. E say “All these cigars, even if na big man own, fit kill person or bring sickness. No kind tobacco product suppose dey without law.”
Oga Carr even yan about wetin National Cancer Institute talk say “This cigar smoking fit cause cancer for mouth, throat and chest.”
For court, di health group dem warn say if dem leave this big man cigar without law, e fit make people think say e safe pass other one because dem no dey control am.
How Di Cigar Fight Start 🥊🚬
This F.D.A. wahala to control cigar na from one law wey dem call Tobacco Control Act for 2009. That time na Congress give F.D.A. di power to dey look into cigarette and smokeless tobacco mata. For 2014, F.D.A. come say make dem put law for cigar too.
Dem ask public people wetin dem think if dem fit dey soft on top how dem dey control this correct cigars. Cigar Rights of America wey be group wey dey talk for cigar people come dey beg F.D.A. say make dem no too put hand, say people wey dey smoke am no plenty and dem no dey too drag am inside.
This group still come dey argue say na only old men dey smoke am and say those kind people no need di protection wey di law wan give.
But F.D.A. come talk say make all di cigar people dey show wetin dey inside dia product and make dem dey register am every year. Dem talk say di cigar people no show dem correct tori wey go make dem no put law for them. So, di agency come decide say make dem dey control all cigar the same way to protect everybody well well.
Di people wey dey support cigar come dey drag F.D.A. go court.
Di Big Mata ⚖️🔍
F.D.A. still get plenty work to do about that 2009 law. Plenty people still dey challenge am for court, especially as dem dey try remove plenty e-cigarette products.
Michael Edney, lawyer wey dey represent di cigar people, talk say this new rule get bigger meaning for how dem go dey control tobacco. E say court talk say, if F.D.A. wan put law for some kind tobacco, e no easy like dat.
American Lung Association talk say dem still dey look di mata to know di next move. As for F.D.A., dem no talk anything about di wahala for now.
Nobody know yet if F.D.A. go challenge this rule or leave am like dat.
NOW IN BLACK AMERICAN SLANG
🚫🚬 Judge Shuts Down F.D.A. Moves on Them Luxury Cigars
Aight, so peep this: On Wednesday, a federal judge was like, “Nah, F.D.A., y’all can’t be regulating these high-end, hand-rolled cigars like that.” This was a big win for the folks making them fancy cigars we often see on the big screen and during some lit parties.
Back in 2016, these cigar bosses started pushin’ back against the F.D.A.’s rules. Their grind paid off big time last year when U.S. District Judge Amit P. Mehta said the F.D.A. was way off in how they were trying to handle these premium cigars, especially considering they’re all about reducing tobacco use with their other rules.
Now, we ain’t talkin’ about those machine-made ones you find at the corner store. We talkin’ about them hand-made luxury cigars that you might cop from some high-end spots.
When Drew Newman, who’s runnin’ J.C. Newman Cigar Co. down in Tampa, Fla., heard the news, he went and found one of them old-school cigars his grandpops made. Dude lit it up, feeling good that their family legacy gonna keep shining for the next gens.
Mixed Feelings on the Court Move 💃🚫
But hold up, not everybody was feeling that same energy. Some big-time health groups, like the American Lung Association and the American Heart Association, were real tight about it. They wanted those regulations to stick around.
Thomas Carr, the big dog at the American Lung Association, was mad salty about the whole thing. He was like, “All cigars, fancy or not, are dangerous. Every tobacco product should have some kinda rules, straight up.”
He also threw in some science, saying cigars can cause some serious health problems, like cancer.
And these health groups? They’re worried folks gonna think that just ’cause these luxury cigars ain’t regulated, they’re all good. That ain’t the case.
Where This Whole Cigar Drama Started 🥊🚬
So, here’s the backstory: In 2009, Congress gave the F.D.A. mad power over cigarettes and smokeless tobacco with the Tobacco Control Act. By 2014, the F.D.A. started lookin’ at cigars too.
They even asked folks what they thought about regulating them fancy cigars a little more chill. Groups like Cigar Rights of America told the F.D.A. to ease up. They said not everyone’s puffing these expensive cigars every day.
But the F.D.A. wasn’t hearing it. They told these premium cigar makers they had to break down what’s in their products and check in every year.
After all that, some groups that were down for the cigar industry decided to take things to court.
Looking at the Whole Scene ⚖️🔍
The F.D.A. is still doing its thing with that 2009 law, even with all the legal heat they’re catching, especially ’cause they’re trying to get some e-cigarette products off the streets.
Michael Edney, a lawyer for the cigar side of things, said this recent move is bigger than just cigars. He’s saying it ain’t simple deciding which tobacco products to regulate.
The American Lung Association is currently choppin’ it up with other health groups to see what’s next. The F.D.A., on the other hand, kept it on the low and didn’t wanna talk about the court stuff.
Now, everybody’s waiting to see if the F.D.A. is gonna come back at this decision.
NOW IN ENGLISH
🚫🚬 Judge Overturns F.D.A. Regulation on Luxury Cigars
In a surprising turn of events, a federal judge ruled against the Food and Drug Administration’s (F.D.A.) oversight on premium hand-rolled cigars on Wednesday. This decision brings joy to producers of these upscale products, often showcased in movies and festive occasions.
Since 2016, cigar manufacturers have been in legal disputes with the F.D.A. over this particular regulation. Their perseverance seemed to have paid off last year when U.S. District Judge Amit P. Mehta found the F.D.A.’s approach towards these luxury cigars as inconsistent under the broader federal law focusing on curbing tobacco consumption.
This ruling specifically pertains to hand-crafted cigars, typically sold in specialty boxes and upscale shops, differentiating them from the mass-produced, machine-made cigars frequently found in regular stores.
Upon hearing the news, Drew Newman, the top executive of J.C. Newman Cigar Co. in Tampa, Fla., fetched a vintage cigar, once rolled by his grandfather. Newman lit the cigar in a celebratory manner, expressing his gratitude that their age-old family craft could continue to be passed down to future generations.
Mixed Reactions to the Decision 💃🚫
However, not everyone shared Newman’s enthusiasm. Renowned health organizations like the American Lung Association, American Heart Association, and others such as the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Cancer Society, had previously submitted court documents urging the retention of the regulations.
Expressing his discontentment, Thomas Carr, the chief of policy at the American Lung Association, labeled the decision as deeply troubling. He emphasized, “All cigars, even the premium ones, are potentially fatal and health-hazardous. Every tobacco item, irrespective of its class, requires some degree of regulation.”
Supporting his point, Carr referenced the National Cancer Institute’s findings that link cigar smoking to cancers of the mouth, throat, and lungs.
Additionally, in their court submission, these health organizations cautioned against exempting these cigars from regulation, warning that such a move could falsely imply that luxury cigars are less harmful due to their unregulated status.
Origins of the Cigar Dispute 🥊🚬
The root of this regulatory squabble traces back to the Tobacco Control Act of 2009. Congress, under this act, endowed the F.D.A. with substantial powers over cigarettes and smokeless tobacco. By 2014, the F.D.A. had initiated steps to regulate cigars as well.
During this period, the public’s opinion was sought on whether a more lenient stance could be adopted for regulating high-end cigars. Advocacy groups like Cigar Rights of America encouraged the F.D.A. to act with restraint, highlighting that premium cigar consumption was not a daily habit for many, with several consumers even opting not to inhale.
Further arguments presented claimed that the majority of these cigar aficionados were seasoned adults, who didn’t necessarily need the protective measures the legislation aimed to provide.
In response, the F.D.A. mandated that premium cigar producers conduct thorough evaluations of their products, disclose their ingredients, and register annually. The F.D.A. underscored the cigar industry’s failure to present convincing data regarding health risks or youthful consumption, thus justifying the necessity for a uniform regulatory approach.
In retaliation, pro-cigar factions initiated legal proceedings.
The Bigger Landscape ⚖️🔍
The F.D.A. continues its work, ensuring compliance with the pivotal 2009 legislation. Amidst its endeavors, the agency frequently encounters legal objections, especially as it aims to eliminate a myriad of e-cigarette products from the market.
Michael Edney, a legal representative for the cigar claimants, suggested that the recent judgment has wider implications for tobacco regulation. He inferred that regulating certain tobacco products is not straightforward and requires meticulous consideration.
Concurrently, discussions regarding this verdict are underway within the American Lung Association and other health bodies. As for the F.D.A.’s stance, the agency chose not to comment on the ongoing legal matter.
It remains uncertain whether the F.D.A. will appeal against this decision.
